Yeah I meant 2 attack songs, not a single song that doubles your attack
/COR like /BRD only allows you to have one buff from the sub. Given that unless you're lucky (and get the lucky number) you'll either have a half-assed gimp buff or will risk for a better roll (namely IX-XI). If you Bust you won't be able to try again for another 5mins whereas a COR main will still have one open slot to give out Rolls.
I don't remember how badly a Bust "gimps" you but the potency of a Bust when subbed is almost as potent as if it was from main COR.
Bust only gimps the COR or /COR.
Fighter's Roll is also 40+ (I think 56 but it's been a while). ALL the "good" (i.e. well liked) rolls are 38+ and therefore not subbable.
I'd go as far to say; Fighter's Roll XI + WAR > Two attack songs.
Or maybe even a Lucky number (V) instead of XI. Also replace "Fighter's" with "Rogue's" and "WAR" with "THF" and it'd still be better.
Also Evoker's + Healer's Roll > Balladx2 or Refresh (if healer is SMN or WHM). Only time this isn't the case is if there isn't much time to sit down and heal (merits much?

).
What most people
DON'T know is that a COR's "usefulness" is very dependant on what jobs are in his/her party. I could give Fighter's Roll and Rogue's Roll but without WAR and THF in party they mean practically sh*t. Chaos Roll with a DRK is very nice and matches two attack songs from a BRD (can probably be better if Lucky or XI).
Being a COR myself I'd have to say if you don't have either a WAR, DRK or THF in party then don't invite a COR. You'd be better off with another DD unless you need an unreliable form of Refresh.
Tsybil wrote:Well the HOT endgame party used to be RDM + BRD + 4 melee/NIN. Now its RDM + BRD + COR + 3 melee/NIN.
Good to know that with elitism comes stupidity (not calling you a stupid elitest, just the people who only want these setups

). Replacing a DD with a COR is a loss of damage, even with an Enhanced Fighter's Roll the damage the COR brings to the table both direct and indirect does not match up to a pure DD at that level.
Doesn't bother me though, I still get the invites
Several times a forming party has asked me "Can't find a BRD, will a COR do?" Seeing as I think a SNM or WHM would work, OF COURSE a COR will do. I do not tell them this in quite that way.
You may be happy to find out that SMN and WHM make better use of a COR than RDM does (think Shirai would be anyways

). SMN get enhanced Evoker's Roll, which is really quite sexy (2-5mp/tick), and WHM gets enhanced Healer's Roll, RDM however doesn't make use of either. RDM+COR = bad combo without a healer.
Don't even get me started on subjobs, I managed to proove /WHM is always bettered by either /RNG or /NIN in every possible EXP/merit scenario on the KI COR forum.
/really ending rant this time... perhaps.